Understanding Gottman's Stonewalling: The Silent Destructor of Relationships

written by Bracey Dangerfield, M.S.

Monday, October 23, 2023

In the intricate tapestry of relationships, emotions are the threads that weave the bonds of connection. Yet, within this tapestry, there exists a pattern that, if left unaddressed, can unravel the fabric of even the most resilient relationships. This pattern is stonewalling – a behavior dissected and studied by Dr. John Gottman, offering profound insights into the dynamics of emotional withdrawal. In this exploration, we embark on a journey to unravel the enigma of stonewalling, delving into its origin, impact, and the tools at our disposal to overcome its silent barriers and foster deeper connections.

Whether you're in a long-standing partnership or just beginning to understand the intricacies of relationships, the concept of stonewalling is essential to comprehend. It's not just about silence; it's about understanding the emotional complexities that underlie this behavior. So, let's dive deeper into the heart of stonewalling and discover how it can reshape the course of relationships.

 

What is Stonewalling? Stonewalling is a communication behavior characterized by shutting down, withdrawing, and emotionally disengaging from a conversation or interaction with a partner. It often involves one partner giving the silent treatment, avoiding eye contact, or displaying a lack of responsiveness. While stonewalling may seem passive, it is a potent expression of emotional distance and can lead to escalating conflicts and deteriorating emotional intimacy.

 

The Impact of Stonewalling on Relationships:

  1. Breakdown of Communication: Stonewalling prevents open and productive communication, leaving issues unresolved and festering beneath the surface.
  2. Emotional Isolation: The stonewalled partner can feel rejected, unheard, and unimportant, leading to emotional isolation.
  3. Escalating Conflict: When one partner stonewalls, the other might feel frustrated and unheard, leading to more intense arguments and conflicts.
  4. Erosion of Trust: Consistent stonewalling can erode trust between partners, signaling a lack of emotional availability and investment in the relationship.
  5. Diminished Intimacy: Emotional distance resulting from stonewalling can lead to reduced emotional and physical intimacy.

Why Do People Stonewall? Stonewalling often stems from a combination of factors, including:

  1. Overwhelm: One partner may become overwhelmed by emotions and feel the need to withdraw to manage their feelings.
  2. Avoidance of Conflict: Some individuals stonewall as a way to avoid confrontations and uncomfortable discussions.
  3. Defense Mechanism: Stonewalling can be a defense mechanism against feeling attacked or criticized.

 

Strategies to Address and Overcome Stonewalling:

  1. Recognize Patterns: Become aware of the stonewalling behavior and its triggers. Identifying patterns can help both partners address the issue more effectively.
  2. Create Safe Spaces: Foster an environment where both partners feel safe to express their thoughts and emotions without fear of judgment or criticism.
  3. Take Breaks, Not Withdrawals: Instead of completely shutting down, agree on taking short breaks during heated discussions. Set a time to reconvene and continue the conversation with a clearer mindset.
  4. Practice Active Listening: Both partners should actively listen to understand each other's perspectives rather than focusing solely on their own reactions.
  5. Use "I" Statements: Use "I" statements to express feelings and concerns, which can help avoid triggering defensiveness in the listener.
  6. Seek Professional Help: If stonewalling becomes a chronic issue, consider seeking the guidance of a couples therapist or counselor who can provide tailored strategies to overcome the behavior.

 

Stonewalling, though often seen as a silent behavior, can speak volumes about the health of a relationship. Understanding the impact of stonewalling, its underlying causes, and employing effective strategies to address and overcome this behavior can be crucial in maintaining a strong and fulfilling partnership. By fostering open communication, emotional connection, and mutual respect, couples can navigate through conflicts and challenges while strengthening the bonds that hold their relationship together.